It’s at all times unbelievable how shortly The Great British Baking Show on Netflix will get us to fall in love with a brand new crop of bakers. Two weeks in and I already would die for Maxy, giggle over Janusz kvetching that he’s going to cry, and cheer when Sandro talks about smashing gender stereotypes. The darkish facet of connecting so quick with a brand new solid of bakers is the whiplash that comes when we’ve to right away say goodbye to somebody beautiful. So it was with The Great British Baking Show “Biscuit Week.” While Maxy took dwelling Star Baker, candy, 18-year-old Maisam was despatched dwelling.

But did Maisam should be eradicated this week on The Great British Baking Show? As judges Paul Hollywood and Prue Leith identified, her Showstopper Venetian masquerade masks was a “good” design, with Paul calling it “easy, however efficient.” Prue beloved her butterfly biscuits. Maisam was additionally center of the pack in the course of the Technical and did fairly good together with her signature. There wasn’t a single catastrophe. So why did she go dwelling when Carole and Rebs — who each had points with their Showstoppers — bought to remain?

Were Paul Hollywood and Prue Leith proper to ship Maisam dwelling? Or did they already botch a judging this early within the season?

Maxy, Rebs, and James hugging Maisam in 'The Great British Baking Show' "Biscuit Week"
Photo: Netflix

The first three episodes of any Great British Baking Show are extra about testing to see if the bakers have the fundamentals down than anything. For Episode 2 “Biscuit Week,” Paul and Prue requested the bakers to make 18 an identical ornamental macarons, 12 Garibaldi biscuits, and a three-dimensional biscuit masks. Easy proper? (I imply, in comparison with what everyone knows is coming.)

By and enormous, the bakers all appeared to do fairly properly this week. Paul and Prue’s largest critiques within the Signature Challenge got here all the way down to flavors — individuals both had an excessive amount of or too little — and a scarcity of ornament. Our backside three bakers this week all had slight wobbles on this problem. Rebs’s macarons have been scrumptious, however splooshed collectively on the final minute with assist from Janusz and firm. So they have been messy as all sin. Carole’s macarons ought to have been extra domed and Paul was upset she used artificial flavoring as a substitute of actual orange zest. Maisam’s textures have been good, however her orange blossom was too robust. She additionally didn’t have time to rigorously embellish her carrot macarons. So, you might say that Maisam, with each a taste and an ornamental knock, was in hassle after this spherical.

Maisam's mask in 'The Great British Baking Show' "Biscuit Week"
Photo: Netflix

Perhaps realizing she was in hassle, Maisam determined to not chunk off greater than she may proverbially chew within the Showstopper. While different bakers tried to bake large quantities of ornamental cookies for his or her masks, Maisam saved issues easy and easy. She used a reasonably easy round form that she embellished with icing and butterfly cookies. It turned out stunning. The factor was…Maisam’s design was so easy that she seemingly completed a very good half hour earlier than time was up. So whereas Rebs raced to complete her masks and Carole fretted over her collapsed gingerbread, Maisam was simply hanging out.

Actually, no, that’s not proper. Maisam wasn’t simply hanging out. She was the one that instantly got here to Carole’s facet. It was actually touching to see {the teenager} consolation the 59-year-old girl as she cried. Maisam embraced the teary-eyed Carole, assuring her it was going to be alright and nobody wished to see her upset. Host Noel Fielding quickly joined within the pep discuss, giving the tent one among its basic moments of camaraderie.

As it occurred, Carole’s bake collapsed due to a failure in her gingerbread recipe that Paul and Prue seized upon early on within the Challenge. Instead of butter, Carole used lard. Too a lot lard, at that. It made the feel of the biscuit too mushy to carry its form. On the intense facet, Carole’s ornamental cookies and macarons have been fantastic, as was her ornament.

Elsewhere, Rebs struggled as soon as extra with time. She once more requested her fellow bakers for assist ending her Showstopper — which isn’t in opposition to the foundations, however is changing into a behavior for Rebs. Prue and Paul have been lower than impressed with Rebs’s bake, calling it too spicy, mushy, and small. And Prue gave Red a scalding backhanded praise: “I feel you might be a fascinator designer. Or a milliner.” (Ouch. This is a baking competitors! Not mask-making one!)

Maisam comforting Carole in 'The Great British Baking Show' "Biscuit Week"
Photo: Netflix

So you’ll assume that with Carole and Rebs’s troubles with the Showstopper and Maisam’s respectable overview, the teenager can be wonderful. Instead, Paul and Prue determined that Carole and Rebs would keep one other week and Maisam would pack her luggage. But was it the correct selection? Was it honest?

If you simply have a look at the Signature and Showstopper, I feel Rebs or Carole would have gone dwelling. The factor is Rebs got here in first on the Technical, which normally provides bakers a reprieve from the chopping block, and Carole was fourth. Maisam was lifeless within the center with seventh place. So Rebs was saved by her Technical and Carole by the truth that she edged out Maisam within the first two challenges.

But what actually despatched Maisam dwelling was satirically her lack of ambition. I say “satirically” as a result of Paul himself prompt in the beginning of the episode that the bakers ought to attempt to not overdo it in these early weeks. Nevertheless, when the judges have been confronted with the extraordinary creativity from bakers like Maxy, Abdul, Syabira, and extra, Maisam’s masks wasn’t as much as snuff.

Maisam’s elimination, whereas tragic, was honest. Rebs was first within the technical and Carole solely made one main mistake. Maisam wasn’t eradicated as a result of her bakes have been unhealthy, however as a result of this yr’s crop of bakers are already pushing themselves to dazzle the judges with their creativity.

If Maisam’s elimination indicators something it’s that that is going to be a really aggressive season of The Great British Baking Show certainly.

: .